I Wanna Play A Game, But I Don't Know What I Want To Play
 

You understand my predicament? Good.

In the poll are some games that are calling out to me, but feel free to suggest others. The only handheld I have and use right now is the 3DS, and I have a Wii and a 360 and the backwards compatibility that comes with those. I also have a PS2 but it's in really sorry shape, but it still plays games. I'm not really big on PC games.

Edit: I wish we had more poll options, but here are a few more:
Donkey Kong 64 (Never Beat)
Starfox 64 (Never Beat)
Resident Evil REmake (Never Beat)
Super Mario World

I'd say Skyward Sword, since I also haven't finished it yet.

Also you must finish P0rtal 2, that should definitely be on your to-do list :P.

I had just beaten the Ancient Cistern in Skyward Sword and for some reason never picked it back up again. That was about two or three years ago.

Portal 2 I'm very close to the end. I'd just gotten out of old Aperture and stopped for the night, but life got in the way and I just haven't picked it up since. It's only been a few months though.

I'm not the biggest fan of Skyward Sword but that's down to personal taste I think, so if I were you I'd do that. Definitely recommend finishing Portal 2 if you're near the end, as well as DKCR. If you had to replay just one of the games up there you have completed, (I assume the ones without brackets) I'd make it Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door, unless you've done it to death. I meant to also vote for Super Mario Galaxy and realised too late, but I'd recommend at least one of the two Galaxy games.

I've not played Super Mario RPG and I don't remember an awful lot about the original Perfect Dark, so ignore the fact I've not voted for them.

Paper Mario, Super Mario RPG, Portal 2, and Super Mario Galaxy are all good games.

Before you jump into any of them though, do a quick playthrough of Star Fox 64. it's really really awesome, and really short. You'll beat it in less than a day, it's a really arcadey game, it isn't even long enough to warrant the ability to save.

Pikmin 2 isn't on the list but if you liked the first one check it out.

You haven't beaten portal 2?

....
DO IT
And if you want to do co-op I can do that with you too :)

Paper Mario is winning right now in the poll. If I play that, what should I name my Yoshi?

Waluigi.

I would say beat the games you haven't beaten yet. As for the ones I voted specifically:

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Never Beat)
If you just beat the Ancient Cistern, than you just beat the best boss in the game. You're also more than halfway done with the game with only 3 (and a half) dungeons left.

Super Mario Galaxy (Never Beat)
WHAT!? Do you even own Mario Galaxy 2? These are great games with fun gameplay! Finish them!

Super Smash Brothers Brawl (Unlock More Things)
If you didn't accidentally use your hammers like I did, then unlocking some Stickers and Trophies is always a fun time-waster in Brawl.

Donkey Kong Country Returns (Never Beat)
I don't know if own Tropical Freeze, but both games have excellent level design.

Perfect Dark (Never Beat)
I'm sure you already know this, but it's a pretty short game. Playing it on harder difficulties has you do more stuff.

Perfect Dark Zero (Never Played)
I'm playing this game myself and I kind of gave up in the forest level, but at least you could say that you've beaten every Rare game.

Portal 2 (Never Beat)
A short game with a predictable story, the game really shines in multiplayer. The multiplayer also has great DLC too.

Super Mario RPG (Never Played)
I haven't played it either, but everyone in the world loves it. Give it a try.

I wouldn't say Super Mario RPG is as good as the Paper Mario games, in fact it's a much more traditional RPG entirely, but if you like traditional RPGs, it's pretty great.

Looking at the poll, wow, has nobody here played Beyond Good & Evil? Really awesome adventure game with a sequel stuck in Development Hell.

I just started replaying Beyond Good and Evil yesterday and it is so good. Do that one!

Beyond Good & Evil is totally ****ing awesome, but there are some other games on that list that you really should play.

About to replay Thousand Year Door myself. It's one of the best games ever made so of course you should play it. While I personally wasn't a fan of Super Mario Galaxy I'd say it's at least worth finishing. Portal 2 is one you must finish. Also if you need a partner for Co-op I have it 360, PS3, and Steam.

Oh wow, TTYD and Portal 2 are tied.

TTYD I think I've beatem fully about three or four times and it's easily in my top ten favorite games.

I might finish up Portal 2 though because I don't have much left to do.